Jump to content

Penalty Shoot Outs


historyman

Recommended Posts

I knew at the end of extra time that we were out. We are worse at penalty shoot outs than England against Germany. I was at the Tennent Caledonian Cup in 79 & I don't think I have seen us win one since. It didn't help when Brophy took that stupid stance before his and before anyone slates me I love Eamonn as a player. The wee man has a rocket of a shot. Why didn't he just blast it.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We also beat Brighton on penalties in the semi-Final of the Tenent Caledonian cup; we made that hard though as Alan Robertson took the 5th kick to win and missed. We won I think on the 6th kick, possibly Ian Gibson.

We were involved in one of the first ever penalty shoot outs in a two legged Ayrshire Cup final, I'm thinking around early seventies and Alex Cairns took one. I can't remember if we won or not!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, Fankle said:

 

According to Everygame we did indeed lose on penalties to Morton in the 79-80 league cup.

Dundee knocked us out of the Anglo-Scottish cup on away goals that season though.

We did actually win a couple of other shoot outs in the 80s league cups, v Alloa and Cowdenbeath.

 

My memory isn't so good then. I thought I remembered that game really well as it was one of the most exciting of that era (was it a QF?) but clearly I couldn't even remember the penalty kicks!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It was bobby street that hit the bar and it did soar straight up into the air. This miss cost us the penalty shootout. The goal to get us back on level terms was scored by paul clark .We had lost the first leg 3-2.So then 90 minutes 3-3 we ended up winning the game 3-2 so a 5-5 aggregate score hence the penalties.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 14/03/2018 at 6:26 PM, Scooby_Doo said:

Who is our fifth taker there? I got Bell, Fowler, Clancy, Hamill ??

Robin Shroot?  Kiote also played in that tourney.  Dayton made his debut and Medhi was a class above at times.  

Think it was against Biddeford when there was a lonely soul the other side of the park from most fans cranking out 'Ayr, Ayr, f**k your Ayr'.  Taking the cause to North Devon- impressive level of hatred!

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There was a lot of trialists on that tour - Dayton, Letheren, Silva, Sissoko, Shroot and Kioyo who was a Cameroun/ German. 

The penalty kicker doesn't look like Shroot. The only match report I can find says that the only kicker who missed was Kelly but it’s not him. 

Could it be Daniel McKay, who was on the tour and scored a penalty in another match? 

 

Edited by skygod
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 14/03/2018 at 11:48 PM, Fankle said:

 

According to Everygame we did indeed lose on penalties to Morton in the 79-80 league cup.

Dundee knocked us out of the Anglo-Scottish cup on away goals that season though.

We did actually win a couple of other shoot outs in the 80s league cups, v Alloa and Cowdenbeath.

 

I was at the Alloa game...we then lost a penalty shoot out at Dens Park in the next round.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 hours ago, skygod said:

There was a lot of trialists on that tour - Dayton, Letheren, Silva, Sissoko, Shroot and Kioyo who was a Cameroun/ German. 

The penalty kicker doesn't look like Shroot. The only match report I can find says that the only kicker who missed was Kelly but it’s not him. 

Could it be Daniel McKay, who was on the tour and scored a penalty in another match? 

 

Was there not a young American lad there or someone who had come through the US college system?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Stats for every competitive penalty shoot out involving Killie.

A grand total on 6 wins out of 18. Only 2 victories out of 11 in national cup competitions in 1982 and 1984.  Read it and weep:

1/5/1971 Ayrshire Cup Final v Ayr United(H) 2-2 on aggregate(Lost 4-5 on pens-Sudden Death)

Scored: Jim McSherry, Alex Cairns, Jim McCulloch, Alan McDonald

Missed: Jim Whyte, Billy Dickson, Jackie McGrory

8/5/74 Ayrshire Cup Final v Ayr United(H) 1-1(Won 5-4 on pens)

Scored: Ian Fleming, George Maxwell, Eddie Morrison, Alan Robertson, Gordon Smith

Missed:No one!

9/5/77 Ayrshire Cup Final v Ayr United(H) 2-2(Lost 5-6 on pens-Sudden Death)

Scored: George Maxwell, Billy Murdoch, Alan Robertson, Iain McCulloch, Stuart McLean

Missed: Paul Clarke

3/8/79 Tennent Caledonian Cup Semi Final v Brighton(N) 1-1(Won 6-5 on pens-Sudden Death)

Scored: Ian Gibson, Ian Jardine, Jim Hughes, Derrick McDicken, Stuart McLean, George Maxwell

Missed: Alan Robertson

5/8/79 Tennent Caledonian Cup Final v Rangers(A) 2-2 (Won 5-3 on pens)

Scored: Ian Jardine, Jim Hughes Stuart McLean, Alistair Mauchlen, Bobby Street

Missed:No one!

24/11/79 League Cup Quarter Final v Morton(H) 5-5 on aggregate(Lost 3-5 on pens)

Scored: Ian Gibson, Joe Cairney, Stuart McLean

Missed: Bobby Street

24/9/80 League Cup 3rd Round v Dundee(H) 0-0 on aggregate(Lost 3-5 on pens)

Scored: Jim Clark, Bobby Houston, Stuart McLean

Missed: George Maxwell

8/9/82 League Cup v Cowdenbeath(A) 1-1 on aggregate (Won 4-3 on pens)

Scored: Stuart McLean, Sam McGivern, Jim Clark, Alistair McLeod

Missed: Ian Bryson

22/8/84 League Cup 2nd Round v Alloa Athletic (H) 1-1 (Won 3-2 on pens)

Scored: Stuart McLean, Derrick McDicken, Sam McGivern

Missed: Robert Clark, Paul Clarke

29/8/84 League Cup 3rd Round v Dundee (A) 1-1 (Lost 2-3 on pens)

Scored: Derrick McDicken, Stuart McLean,

Missed: Bobby McConville,Robert Clark Sam McGivern

6/1/90 Scottish Cup 2nd Round replay v Stranraer (H) 0-0 (Lost 3-4 on pens)

Scored: Dave McKinnon, Tom Callaghan, Willie Watters

Missed: Tommy Burns, Paul Flexney

4/2/92 Scottish Cup 3rd round replay v Meadowbank Thistle (H) 1-1 (Lost 3-4 on pens)

Scored: Tom Black, Hugh Burns, Calum Campbell

Missed: Mark Roberts, Tommy Burns

12/10/93 Ayrshire Cup Final v Ayr United (H) 3-3 (Won 3-2 on pens Sudden Death)

Scored:Ian Porteous, Tom Brown, Mark Roberts

Missed: Billy Stark, David White, Danny Crainie

9/10/2001 League Cup 3rd Round v Ayr United (A) 0-0 (Lost 4-5 on pens Sudden Death)

Scored: Freddie Dindeleux, Alan Mahood, Kris Boyd, Andy McLaren

Missed: Craig Dargo, Chris Innes

24/9/2002 League Cup 2nd round v Airdrie United (H) 0-0 (Lost 3-4 on pens)

Scored: Jesus Sanjuan, Steve Fulton, Kris Boyd

Missed: Alan Mahood, Gary Hay

24/7/2004 West Sound Trophy v Ayr United (A) 2-2 (Lost 4-5 on pens)

Scored: Peter Leven, Craig Dargo, Kris Boyd, Freddie Dindeleux

Missed: Gary Wales

31/7/2016 League Cup Group Stage v Albion Rovers (H) (Lost 3-5 on pens)

Scored: Flo Bojaj, Steven Smith, Gary Dicker

Missed: Josh Magennis

13/3/2018 League Cup Quarter Final Replay v Aberdeen (H) 1-1 (Lost 2-3 on pens)

Scored: Lee Erwin, Stephen O'Donnell

Missed: Eamon Brophy, Greg Taylor, Greg Kiltie

There is one stat which will probably surprise every Killie fan over 40. Can you spot it?

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

48 minutes ago, The Deserter said:

Stats for every competitive penalty shoot out involving Killie.

A grand total on 6 wins out of 18. Only 2 victories out of 11 in national cup competitions in 1982 and 1984.  Read it and weep:

1/5/1971 Ayrshire Cup Final v Ayr United(H) 2-2 on aggregate(Lost 4-5 on pens-Sudden Death)

Scored: Jim McSherry, Alex Cairns, Jim McCulloch, Alan McDonald

Missed: Jim Whyte, Billy Dickson, Jackie McGrory

8/5/74 Ayrshire Cup Final v Ayr United(H) 1-1(Won 5-4 on pens)

Scored: Ian Fleming, George Maxwell, Eddie Morrison, Alan Robertson, Gordon Smith

Missed:No one!

9/5/77 Ayrshire Cup Final v Ayr United(H) 2-2(Lost 5-6 on pens-Sudden Death)

Scored: George Maxwell, Billy Murdoch, Alan Robertson, Iain McCulloch, Stuart McLean

Missed: Paul Clarke

3/8/79 Tennent Caledonian Cup Semi Final v Brighton(N) 1-1(Won 6-5 on pens-Sudden Death)

Scored: Ian Gibson, Ian Jardine, Jim Hughes, Derrick McDicken, Stuart McLean, George Maxwell

Missed: Alan Robertson

5/8/79 Tennent Caledonian Cup Final v Rangers(A) 2-2 (Won 5-3 on pens)

Scored: Ian Jardine, Jim Hughes Stuart McLean, Alistair Mauchlen, Bobby Street

Missed:No one!

24/11/79 League Cup Quarter Final v Morton(H) 5-5 on aggregate(Lost 3-5 on pens)

Scored: Ian Gibson, Joe Cairney, Stuart McLean

Missed: Bobby Street

24/9/80 League Cup 3rd Round v Dundee(H) 0-0 on aggregate(Lost 3-5 on pens)

Scored: Jim Clark, Bobby Houston, Stuart McLean

Missed: George Maxwell

8/9/82 League Cup v Cowdenbeath(A) 1-1 on aggregate (Won 4-3 on pens)

Scored: Stuart McLean, Sam McGivern, Jim Clark, Alistair McLeod

Missed: Ian Bryson

22/8/84 League Cup 2nd Round v Alloa Athletic (H) 1-1 (Won 3-2 on pens)

Scored: Stuart McLean, Derrick McDicken, Sam McGivern

Missed: Robert Clark, Paul Clarke

29/8/84 League Cup 3rd Round v Dundee (A) 1-1 (Lost 2-3 on pens)

Scored: Derrick McDicken, Stuart McLean,

Missed: Bobby McConville,Robert Clark Sam McGivern

6/1/90 Scottish Cup 2nd Round replay v Stranraer (H) 0-0 (Lost 3-4 on pens)

Scored: Dave McKinnon, Tom Callaghan, Willie Watters

Missed: Tommy Burns, Paul Flexney

4/2/92 Scottish Cup 3rd round replay v Meadowbank Thistle (H) 1-1 (Lost 3-4 on pens)

Scored: Tom Black, Hugh Burns, Calum Campbell

Missed: Mark Roberts, Tommy Burns

12/10/93 Ayrshire Cup Final v Ayr United (H) 3-3 (Won 3-2 on pens Sudden Death)

Scored:Ian Porteous, Tom Brown, Mark Roberts

Missed: Billy Stark, David White, Danny Crainie

9/10/2001 League Cup 3rd Round v Ayr United (A) 0-0 (Lost 4-5 on pens Sudden Death)

Scored: Freddie Dindeleux, Alan Mahood, Kris Boyd, Andy McLaren

Missed: Craig Dargo, Chris Innes

24/9/2002 League Cup 2nd round v Airdrie United (H) 0-0 (Lost 3-4 on pens)

Scored: Jesus Sanjuan, Steve Fulton, Kris Boyd

Missed: Alan Mahood, Gary Hay

24/7/2004 West Sound Trophy v Ayr United (A) 2-2 (Lost 4-5 on pens)

Scored: Peter Leven, Craig Dargo, Kris Boyd, Freddie Dindeleux

Missed: Gary Wales

31/7/2016 League Cup Group Stage v Albion Rovers (H) (Lost 3-5 on pens)

Scored: Flo Bojaj, Steven Smith, Gary Dicker

Missed: Josh Magennis

13/3/2018 League Cup Quarter Final Replay v Aberdeen (H) 1-1 (Lost 2-3 on pens)

Scored: Lee Erwin, Stephen O'Donnell

Missed: Eamon Brophy, Greg Taylor, Greg Kiltie

There is one stat which will probably surprise every Killie fan over 40. Can you spot it?

 

 

 

Tommy Burns missed two out of two penalties in shoot-outs for Killie?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

49 minutes ago, killie1961 said:

Myself as well Bickering Bush Bus

Me too. John Player Norton. Drove back to the Jolly Farmers after the game & some of the guys who had left early didn't even know we had scored 2 goals in the last 4 minutes to take it to penalties. The look on their faces when I told them we had won on penalties was priceless. In fact when I went into work the next day one of the guys was reading the Record & he said to me I hate losing to those H**n bastards. I said "Josie, look at the sport pages" Haha, I have never left early from a game since. I have an old Shoot magazine somewhere which shows us getting presented with the cup on the front cover & you can see me jumping in the background in the old Ibrox enclosure. If I can find it I will post the pic.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That's a pretty impressive record from the spot. I don't actually remember Stuart McLean getting the abuse that is sometimes mentioned in the forum. 

I thought he was a good player for us and of course he was part of that fantastic back five for many years.

Speaking of which, having seen the interview with PC I would love to see the 5 of them reunited to do the half time draw at a home game. They must have well over 1,000 appearances between them.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...